ORANGE PEEL ON BMW CARS EXPLAINED

Author: Andre Clemente, Founder of New Old Cars, LLC ©
Proud owner of an E39 540i 6spd
Last updated: March 29, 2020

 

You may be wondering why BMW received a lot of attention in our article regarding orange peel. In fact, that “attention” can be felt all over the internet. Swimming through the forums will reveal just how often people complain about the paint on their Bimmers. While the orange peel problem isn’t unique to the Bavarians, they seem to receive more complaints about orange peel than any other luxury car maker. Understandably, vehicles at this price point have customers with high expectations – and a demand for answers when they’re not happy. So what’s the deal?

Don’t bother asking the salesman. The problem is due to the natural chemistry of BMW’s advanced powdered clear coat – a paint technology they have been using since 1998.

bmw orange peel paint quality
 
You see, the conventional liquid clear coat used on cars from other brands contain solvents. There are different types of solvents for different purposes, but to keep things simple: solvent acts as a leveling agent. It exists to control flow, act as a thinner, and help the paint resist sagging during the drying/curing process. When paint is sprayed on the car, it doesn’t quite hit the surface in a uniform manner (even coming from the factory’s advanced bell cup sprayers), which means that ultra small “hills” and “valleys” form on the surface (we’re talking in the height of microns here). As the solvent begins to evaporate (part of the curing process), it will level out most of this unevenness in the paint. Basically, these “hills” and “valleys” will flow out, leaving a mostly smooth paint finish.

However … BMW’s powdered clear coat has no solvent.

And since powder is a solid and not a liquid, it has no viscosity or flow.

So instead of relying on solvent, BMW has to rely on ultra high baking temperatures to “melt” (or “fuse”) the powder particles to the body. The temperature required from their ovens can reach almost 100 degrees F higher than what’s typical for conventional liquid clearcoats (which is over 300 degrees F as it is). This is a problem, because now BMW has the difficult job of finding the right balance in curing temperature for both the powder clear coat and the waterborne basecoat that lies underneath (which has not yet fully cured at this stage of the paint process). You see, waterborne paint has different flow properties than the powdered clear coat that sits on top. Too high of a temperature can cause problems for waterborne paints – for instance, it may force the paint to cure (finish cross-linking) before it actually has a chance to level itself out. This means the ultra small “hills” and “valleys” we spoke of earlier have less of a chance to even out into a smooth surface.

The effect is worse with the powdered clear coat on top, which naturally resists flow. The unevenness in the surface doesn’t “level out”, so you get these “clumps” of low and high spots (again, think microns in size).

Say hello to the orange peel.
 

BMW exclusively powder coats the clear coat onto their cars, using an advanced clear called Enviracryl by PPG. While BMW “claims” that the basecoat is formulated to work with the powder clear coat, the resulting finish doesn’t seem to show it – just look at the final product.
TAP IMAGE TO REVEAL TEXT
Now, in the refinishing industry, your local body shop will have the luxury to sand and buff out this orange peel from the surface, leaving a brilliant shine. However, automated-savy BMW will not invest in the manual labor required to correct the orange peel from the surface of every car they sell (powdered clearcoat, by the way, requires a bit more labor when it comes to paint correction than the equivalent liquid clear coat). Only the top of the line models and special colors receive the extra cutting treatment, such as BMW’s $10k Pure Metal Silver.

In addition, this powder coat “breakthrough” has cost BMW a lot of money to implement on the their production line. It’s uber expensive, and as a result, no other car company has pursued powdered clear coat technology as of this writing.

So why does BMW swear by it?

 
The answer is simple: longevity, strength, and a paint that is completely VOC free. BMW’s clear coat can hold up to wear and tear better than any other competitor, and it has more resistance to stone chip damage than any other clear coat in the industry.

Pound for pound, you just can’t beat powder coating when it comes to durability. It’s simply the strongest clear coat there is – period.

In regards to cost, the investment has actually paid off in the long run. 95% of the overspray from powder coating can be recycled, leading to exponentially less waste than conventional clear coats. “BMW Dingolfing has realized actual annual energy cost savings of approximately 25%”, reports PCI Magazine.

Waterborne coatings have their own drawbacks, and considering the EPA has been cracking down on VOC emissions from liquid coatings since 2003, powder coating has a bright future in the automotive paint industry. And guess what? BMW will have more experience in the powder coating field than any other manufacturer, putting them ahead of the game.

Question: On which generation of BMW’s did this problem start?

Answer: The E65/E60/E90 series models (the Bangle Butt era). Even though BMW’s powdered coat clear coat was implemented in 1998 with the E39 5 series and E38 7 series, these two models were “testbeds” and in fact had exceptional paint quality (and durability). As time went on, cost cutting meant reducing the film build thickness of the clearcoat from the optimal 80-85 microns to 65 microns on the E65 7 series, E60 5 series, and (especially) the E90 3 series. This reduced some of the durability advantages it had over competitors, and resulted in a more prominent appearance of orange peel.

Today, BMW has officially achieved what was once thought impossible – a powdered clearcoat thickness equivalent to that of their liquid clearcoat competition (40 to 50 microns). This is why the overall paint thickness of new BMW cars will hover around a mere 120 microns.

 

Author:

Andre Clemente, Founder of New Old Cars, LLC ©
Proud owner of an E39 540i 6spd
Article last updated: March 29, 2020

 

Additional Article Sources:

 
BASF Handbook on Basics of Coating Technology, (3rd ed.) 

T. Brock, M. Groteklaes and P. Mischke, “European Coatings Handbook,” Vincentz Verlag, Hannover, 2000.

Film Formation and Surface Tension Studies Of Powder Coatings

Streitberger, Hans-Joachim, and Dössel, Karl-Friedrich. Automotive Paint and Coatings, 2nd Edition. WILEY-VCH Verlag GmBH & Co, 2008.  

…and many more! NOC takes incredible pride in posting only the most accurate information with the help of credible sources. Now, because some links are no longer active, not all sources are posted here. These links have been removed from the source’s website for unknown reasons. However, NOC downloads and retains all sources used to stand by every statement in this article. This is done for all articles on our website, and NOC is happy to share this information with the public. Your trust is our number one priority.

– COMMENTS –

Want to participate in the comments below? Please register with us first >
Already have an account? Login here >
First time commenter? Here’s a quick overview of how the comment section works >